The Rhinos went 15-7-6, and eliminated the Montreal Impact in the first round of the postseason before being eliminated by the Charleston Battery. In the U.S. Open Cup, the Rhinos were eliminated by the New England Revolution.
05-09
05-11
Rochester 2-2 Atlanta
Miller 27', 63'
Attendance: 10,026
Atlanta 0-2 Rochester
Miller 33', 55'
Attendance: 721
05-19
05-23
Toronto 1-1 Rochester
Hayes 12' (P)
​
Attendance: 1,594
Syracuse 0-2 Rochester
Miller 45', Wilson 88'
​
Attendance: 8,057
Rochester 1-2 Syracuse
Semedo 43' (OG)
​
Attendance: 8,495
06-07
06-14
06-15
Rochester 2-0 Pittsburgh
Onaga 54' (OG), Suarez 76'
Attendance: 9,173
Minnesota 1-2 Rochester
Fuller 52', 85'
Attendance: 4,881
Milwaukee 0-3 Rochester
Fuller 11', Miller 27', Wilson 56'
Attendance: 2,468
06-22
Montreal 1-0 Rochester
​
​
Attendance: 5,961
Rochester 6-1 Toronto
Paco 10', Miller 42', Sedgewick 45', Commodore 68', 70', 83'
Attendance: 11,349
07-19
07-22
Rochester 3-2 Virginia Beach (OT)
Miller 36', 92', Demmin 90'
Attendance: 10,060
Richmond 2-0 Rochester
​
​
Attendance: 1,000
Rochester 2-2 Charleston
Fuller 3', Commodore 88'
​
Attendance: 9,487
08-13
08-23
Montreal 0-0 Rochester
​
Attendance: 9,414
Rochester 3-0 Atlanta
Fuller 34', 49', Mendes 69'
Attendance: 10,663
Rochester 3-2 Richmond
Hayes 19', Muller 40, Fuller 53'
Attendance: 12,622
Rochester 2-1 Pittsburgh
Paco 25', Steenkamp 90'
Attendance: 9,063
05-31
Pittsburgh 1-3 Rochester
Steenkamp 20', Miller 23', Fuller 65'
Attendance: 1,277
Rochester 2-3 Montreal (OT)
Miller 35', Steenkamp 49'
Attendance: 10,159
07-06
Toronto 0-2 Rochester
Suarez 6', Wilson 51'
​
Attendance: 2,884
Rochester 2-2 Richmond
Lavyrenko 19', Wilson 90'
​
Attendance: 10,436
08-09
Pittsburgh 4-3 Rochester
Miller 44', Hayes 54', Valencia 68'
Attendance: 2,143
08-29
Syracuse 3-2 Rochester
Suarez 50' (P), Mitchell 60'
Attendance: 9,354
League table to come later
Playoffs
09-05
Rochester 2-1 Montreal
Mladenov 8' (P), Miller 50'
Attendance: 8,339
09-12
09-07
Montreal 0-0 Rochester
​
Attendance: 8,445
Rochester 0-0 Charleston
​
Attendance: 10,017
09-14
Charleston 1-0 Rochester
​
Attendance: 2,571